Cooleaf vs Kudos

Cooleaf

The Bottom Line

The top-down recognition and earning points through challenges and KPIs makes it good for incentivizing performance, but not for those wanting peer-led recognition programs.

Kudos

The Bottom Line

A flexible platform with an emphasis on peer-to-peer recognition and some impressive analytics, though the extra features feel akin to a corporate social network.

How It Works

Cooleaf

All users can give recognition, but only admins and managers can award points. Challenges and performance goals let users earn more points. Points can be exchanged for digital gift cards, swag, or other physical products. Monthly budget determines how many rewards can be redeemed.

Kudos

Users are granted points based on their job title, which can be used to give four types of recognition. Points are refreshed at the start of every month, but users can also give non-monetary recognition. Earned points can be exchanged for gift cards.

The Good

Cooleaf

  • Huge number of integrations and automations
  • Good set of default reports

Kudos

  • Extensive help center
  • Great reporting and analytics
  • Good flexibility for peer-to-peer programs

The Bad

Cooleaf

  • Peer-to-peer recognition is non-monetary
  • No public API
  • Primarily email support

Kudos

  • Can’t adjust points associated with recognition
  • Few charity options and rewards for international users
  • Few chat integrations and limited API

Pricing

Cooleaf

Custom quotes and no public pricing.

Kudos

Custom quotes and no public pricing, but we’ve seen quotes in the range of $2.50-$3.00 per user per month.

Setup & Onboarding

Cooleaf

They setup your account based on your company’s goals, then train you on the platform and prepare you for launch.

Kudos

After signed agreement in place, a client onboarding specialist helps you setup and onboard your users.

UI & UX

Cooleaf

Cooleaf homepage

Fairly modern, though some areas of the platform feel dated. Navigation is simple for normal users and intuitive for admins.

Kudos

Kudos homepage

Stripped down interface with a clean aesthetic – not flashy, but not boring. Easy navigation though there is a small learning curve for admins.

Reward Catalog

Cooleaf

Gift cards, physical products, company swag.

Kudos

Gift cards, charitable donations

Integrations

HRIS

Cooleaf

Workday, BambooHR, ADP, Namely

Kudos

Workday, BambooHR, ADP, SAP, Paylocity, custom HRIS integrations via SFTP

SSO

Cooleaf

Okta, Onelogin

Kudos

Okta, OneLogin, Azure, Google, custom SSO integrations

Common Tool Integrations

Cooleaf

Microsoft Teams, Slack, Facebook Workplace

Kudos

Slack, Microsoft Teams

Additional Integrations

Cooleaf

Linkedin Learning, Lessonly, Salesforce, Zendesk, Salesloft, Lattice, and more.

Kudos

N/A

Analytics & Reports

Cooleaf

Decent set of graphs with a good range of filters. More than a dozen default reports that cover a variety of metrics.

Kudos

Diverse, powerful set of analytics and reporting features.

Support

Cooleaf

Primary support channel is email. The help center features articles that thoroughly cover the basics, but doesn't cover more advanced topics.

Kudos

Chat, email, and weekday phone support. Strong library of help articles that cover basics and advanced topics in great detail.

Extra Features

Cooleaf

Pulse surveys, incentivized in-person or virtual events with in-app registrations and check in, and Android and Apple mobile apps.

Kudos

“Spaces” feature used for storing shared resources and communications across the company. “Albums” feature to share photos across the company. Apple and Android mobile apps.

The Bottom Line

Cooleaf

The top-down recognition and earning points through challenges and KPIs makes it good for incentivizing performance, but not for those wanting peer-led recognition programs.

Kudos

A flexible platform with an emphasis on peer-to-peer recognition and some impressive analytics, though the extra features feel akin to a corporate social network.